RecallSep 8, 2026FI Supplements: Potential to be contaminated with Salmonella
877 products scored223 ingredients explainedNo paid placement

Ingredient library

We'd avoid · Synthetic antioxidant

BHA and BHT

Also appears on labels as: BHA preservative

Synthetic phenolic antioxidants that keep fats from oxidizing, far more durably than vitamin E does.

Watched ingredients get highlighted on every product panel you open.

Where it comes from
Chemical synthesis.
Why it's in the product
Extends shelf life, especially in fat sprayed onto kibble after extrusion.
Safety and toxicity
The International Agency for Research on Cancer classifies BHA as possibly carcinogenic to humans based on high-dose rodent studies, and it appears on California's Prop 65 list. Levels in pet food are far below those study doses. Our objection is exposure pattern: pets eat the same food daily for years, and mixed tocopherols do the same job without the question mark.
Interactions and who should be careful
None established at food levels.

What the research says

BHA keeps fats from going rancid. The International Agency for Research on Cancer lists it as possibly carcinogenic to humans based on tumor findings in high-dose rodent studies, and California's Prop 65 list includes it.

The dose in pet food is far below study levels, but pets eat the same food every day for years, and mixed tocopherols (vitamin E) preserve fat without the question marks. Many premium brands have already dropped BHA, which tells you it isn't necessary.

Placeholder Sources: Source citations for this entry will be linked here once the citations feed is connected. Until then, ask us for the reading list any time: [email protected].

General reference, not veterinary advice. Dose, breed, and existing conditions change the answer, so talk to your vet before changing what your pet eats. Think we got this wrong? Tell us and we log it publicly.

Found in 26 scored products

We flag it by name on 26 of them. Lowest scores first.

Panel Score 40 out of 100, grade F: We'd skip it
Canine Carry OutsSausage Links, Beef Flavorimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 44 out of 100, grade F: We'd skip it
9LivesPlus Careimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 47 out of 100, grade F: We'd skip it
Meow MixTender Centers Salmon & Chicken

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 48 out of 100, grade F: We'd skip it
Kibbles 'n BitsOriginal Savory Beef & Chicken

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 51 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
Milk-BoneSoft & Chewy Training Mini, Filet Mignon

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 51 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
CesarFilet Mignon Flavor & Spring Vegetables Garnish Small Breed Dry

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 52 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
9LivesDaily Essentials Dry Cat Food

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 55 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
Milk-BoneFlavor Snacks Dog Biscuits

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 55 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
Milk-BoneMaroSnacks With Real Bone Marrow

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 55 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
TemptationsBlock Party BBQ Flavor Dry Cat Foodimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 56 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
PurinaBeggin' Strips Original With Bacon

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 56 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
Pup-PeroniOriginal Beef Flavor

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 56 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
Gravy TrainChunks In Gravy With Chicken Chunks

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 59 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
PedigreeComplete Nutrition Adult Roasted Chicken, Rice & Vegetable

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 59 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
Milk-BoneBrushing Chews Daily Dental Treats, Small/Medium

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 59 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
PedigreeTasty Biscuits Peanut Butter Bacon Flavorimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 59 out of 100, grade D: Better options exist
PedigreeAdult Complete Nutrition Grilled Steak & Vegetable Flavorimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 60 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Gravy TrainChunks In Gravy With Beef Chunks

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 60 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Beggin'Purina Beggin Flavor Stix With Peanut Butter Flavorimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 63 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Milk-BoneOriginal Medium Biscuits

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 64 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
WhiskasIndoor Cat Chicken Flavorimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 72 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Bil JacDessert Jacs Pumpkin Flavored Treatsimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

Panel Score 72 out of 100, grade C: Proceed with caution
Bil JacDry Food Senior Select Formula With Chicken & Oatmealimported, not reviewed

flagged on this product's score page

No Panel Score: not enough data
Ol' RoyComplete Nutrition Dry Dog Food

flagged on this product's score page

2 more scored products list this ingredient. Showing the 24 lowest-scoring.