Seafood Medley Cat Treats
Crunchy cat treat · 6.3 ozTreats & chewsScored October 2026
- Flags
- 44 caution
- Ingredients
- 36all in our library
- Brand grade
- Ctransparency, costs 5 points
- Recalls
- 0linked to this product
Save it to your pantry and the pantry page flags it if it turns up in an FDA recall we import.
It adds up, line by line.
Every product starts at 96. Flags, the brand's transparency grade and any recall linked to this product take points away. Nothing else moves the number, and no brand can pay to move it.
Tap a line on the receipt to see which ingredients caused it.
The full methodologyTemptations
Seafood Medley Cat Treats
Good, check the flags
Scored October 2026 · checkthepanel.com
4 flagged ingredients.
Avoid first. Each flag costs points in the score above; where a flag has an entry behind it, it links to the evidence.
Animal fat
Rendered fat from unnamed species, and the ingredient where BHA most often hides.
Meat by-products
Unnamed animal parts. Legal and regulated, but the label tells you nothing about the source.
Natural flavor
An undisclosed blend. Not harmful per se, but it hides what your pet is actually tasting.
Added color
Color added for the buyer's eye, not a synthetic dye; your pet does not care what color it is.
Every ingredient, top to bottom.
Listed by weight, so the first few lines are most of the food. Tap any line to see what it is and why it's there.
36 ingredients. 5 of them carry this product's 4 flags and are marked below. The other 31 raised no flag.
Checked against the brand's own page on Sep 22, 2026. A package on the shelf can be older or newer than that page; trust the one in your hand.
Recall record.
This product
None linked
We link recalls by hand from FDA notices. Only a recall linked to this product counts in its score.
See all pet recallsTemptations, the brand
No FDA recalls on fileNone of the FDA recall notices we have imported names Temptations.
The brand behind it.
Temptations
Mars-owned cat treats built on by-product meal and unnamed animal fat.
Relies on ingredients that don't name their source species. The C grade takes 5 points off this product's score.
Temptations brand pageMore Temptations treats & chews
Panel Score 79 out of 100, grade B: Good, check the flags
Classic Tasty Chicken Cat TreatsPanel Score 79 out of 100, grade B: Good, check the flags
Tasty Chicken FlavorImported, not reviewedPanel Score 79 out of 100, grade B: Good, check the flags
Creamy dairy flavorImported, not reviewedIndependent testing & contaminants
No independent testing on file.
Third-party lab findings for things that never appear on an ingredient label. This is separate from the score above and does not change it.
We haven't found published third-party lab results (PFAS, heavy metals, phthalates) for this product. That is not a clean bill of health, just an absence of data.
What we look forCleaner picks in treats & chews.
Cleaner picks are the highest-scoring products in the same category that suit the same animal. No affiliate links, no paid placement.
This page was corrected 2 times.
- Oct 24, 2026 Panel Score 67 → 75: removed “Unnamed animal ingredients” and the caution for Meat flavor and digest. “Unnamed animal ingredients” was a flag of our own for lines that don't say which animal they come from. We retired it on October 24, 2026 for the entries our library has for those lines, each counted once. The lines behind it already carried Animal fat and Meat by-products, so they were being counted twice. The meat flavor caution came from “Natural Tuna Flavor”. Until October 24, 2026 our library read a natural flavor that names a meat or fish as a meat flavor and digest; it now reads every “natural … flavor” line as a natural flavor, except smoke flavor, which has an entry of its own, and the record already carries Natural flavor for its “Natural Flavors” line, so that entry now counts once.
- Sep 22, 2026 Replaced the summary panel with the ingredient list the brand publishes on its website. Panel Score 63 → 67: added flags for Animal fat, Meat by-products, Added color and Meat flavor and digest, and removed BHA (preservative) and Artificial colors. The earlier panel was written from a search summary in July 2026 and had not been checked. The new list comes from the brand's own website, checked on September 22, 2026.
Holding the package and it reads differently? Disputes come straight to us, and any score we change is logged publicly on the corrections page.